I received an email from You Tube yesterday. Below is what it said.
Your video “Carolina by Sinzu aka Saucekid ft Davido.avi”, may have content that is owned or licensed by iROKING Ltd, but it’s still available on YouTube! In some cases, ads may appear next to it.
This claim is not penalizing your account status. Visit your Copyright Notice page for more details on the policy applied to your video.
– The YouTube Team”
When I visited my Copyright Notice page, below is the relevant copyright notice I got.
Carolina by Sinzu aka Saucekid ft Davido.avi
Your video may include the following copyrighted content:
“yemisax @yemisaxboss www.saxrecordsonline.com-Carolina (Sauce kid & Davido)Yemisax Remix”, sound recording administered by:
To be clear, IROKO/IROKING was not claiming copyright infringement and even if they tried, it would fall flat on its face. However, I was intrigued by the You Tube message for several reasons:
- ‘Carolina’ was my favorite song for 2011.
- Sinzu/Davido’s team sent the song to me and solicited my publishing in my capacity as blogger/publisher, last year etc. If you said, “fair use,” then check you out.
- I knew, for a fact, that Davido/HKN and Sinzu/SMG were not signed to IROKO Ltd. In fact, Sinzu now has his own VEVO account. Second, from all interviews about how ‘Carolina’ came about, Davido said he produced the sound recording and Sinzu jumped on it with the lyrics. Therefore, unless the sound recording was sold to IROKO/Yemi Sax, neither Yemi Sax/nor IROKO can claim to have permission to a song that does not belong to them. Now I am even more intrigued. I start wondering about the Yemi Sax person referenced above. I check on him. He is talented.
I think to myself, “but even if Yemi Sax has permission to create a derivative work off Sinzu’s song, he and IROKO cannot claim copyright ownership to the ORIGINAL sound recording, the one the artists sent to me which is what I published on You Tube in conjunction with the article I wrote last year.”
Folks, if you use pre-existing work such as the sound recording of an artist to create an adaptation, recast it or transform the pre-existing work, then you have created a “derivative work” both under US and Nigerian law. The problem, however, is that the only person who can create or grant the rights for a derivative work to be created is the holder of the copyright of the original work.
Back to Yemi Sax and IROKO, assuming, for argument sake, that Yemi Sax can somehow come up with a copyright ownership agreement that Sinzu granted him, neither him nor IROKO should be trying to claim ownership in the original sound recording. A derivative work doesn’t affect the existing copyright protection granted to the owners of the original work, neither does it erase the permission/right given for use of the original work to a separate party.
In any event, I am bothered by the fact that this Yemi guy is trying to claim ownership of a copyright in the original sound recording of a song that does not belong to him. I contact Sinzu to be clear on copyright ownership of his original sound recording. He was not pleased to hear my experience because he tells me he never licensed his song to IROKO or Yemi Sax, to say the least. He is frustrated with the industry and again confirms that he owns the ‘Carolina’ song with the requisite deal worked out with the producer (Davido), and at no time has he signed with IROKO neither has he given permission to Yemi Sax to perform his work as a derivative, much less make money off it and split the profits with IROKO. He also informs that IROKO solicited him to do business with them and he declined.
Subsequent to my contact with Sinzu, I look at Yemi’s catalog on Iroking and his IROKO You Tube channel. Yemi Sax, make no mistake about it, is very talented. However, he has derivative works of what seems like the entire music industry on both his IROKO Youtube page and Iroking. Now, if neither he nor IROKO bothered to get permission to the song owned by Sinzu, what is the probability that he or IROKO have permission to the many songs Yemi Sax has online?
Hold up. Let’s hit the rewind button on this for a minute people. When IROKO first got on the scene, they went on, and on, and on about protecting the intellectual property rights of artists. I said, “okay. I get it. Now expand your platform beyond You Tube, step up your marketing and promotions for the artist and focus on the artists.” I also added that there were many legal rights involved and this was one sticky situation that could get stickier as the company continued to grow. Y’all saw the exchange on that article. Here we are. So how does IROKO explain this seemingly blatant violation of the copyright of a Nigerian artist? How many more of these exists?
Today, I get a note from You Tube and this is what the new note says:
iROKING Ltd has released its copyright claim on your video, “Carolina by Sinzu aka Saucekid ft Davido.avi”. For more information, please visit your Copyright Notice page
– The YouTube Team”
They must have seen me digging yesterday on their channel.
What happens where your copyright is infringed upon?
You should ask the person infringing to stop through a “cease and desist” letter i.e. take the infringing material off their You Tube page, the music retail stores they are shelved etc. You should also ask them to pay you for damages and profits as a result of the infringement. This can be worked out in a settlement negotiation of some sorts. If they do not take you seriously or ignore you, you take them to court. Be sure to consult with your lawyer to fully discuss your legal rights and also to get legal representation.
I don’t know if IROKO has subsequently taken the Yemi Sax Sinzu ‘Carolina’ rendition off their sites but you can hear the mp3 version of Sax’s unauthorized use below. Any takers who want to discuss this, feel free to do so in the comment section just leave the abuses and attacks out. If not, I will delete it. Argue on the issue and points discussed.
There are a lot more layers and issues here, as you can imagine, but this write up ought to suffice, for now.
AML’s Uploaded ‘Carolina’Song
Yemi Sax’s Unauthorized Use of the Carolina Song
- AML 137: Meet Leyla Konjo, Africa’s Music Industry Top Booking Agent (Interview)
- AML 136: Interview with Cherie Hu, Music Journalist
- AML 135: Artist Manager Bond Stanley Ebigbo on New Book, ‘Grounded Ways to the Music Business.’
- Kenya Music Industry Talks: Life After COVID, What do African Creatives Need to Weather the Impact?
- Nigerian Music Industry Talks: Opportunities for Young Lawyers in the Entertainment Industry